Community treatment orders in New Zealand: regional variability and international comparisons




Anthony J OíBrien

Australasian Psychiatry

August 2014





Objectives: Community treatment orders (CTOs) have been used in New Zealand since 1992 and are now used in most Commonwealth countries. There is little research on the rate of use of CTOs in New Zealand. This study compares the prevalence of CTO use across New Zealandís 20 health districts and makes comparisons with international prevalence rates.

Methods: New Zealand Ministry of Health reports provided data on rates of CTO use in New Zealand between 2005 and 2011. International rates were obtained from published reports and academic literature on CTO use.

Results: Rates of CTO use in New Zealand show marked and persistent regional variation over the period of data collection. National average rates increased from 58 per 100,000 in 2005 to 84 per 100,000 in 2011. Rates of use of CTOs are increasing internationally. New Zealandís CTO use is high by international comparisons.

Conclusions: New Zealandís high and increasing rate of CTO use by international standards raises questions about the delivery and functioning of mental health services, and about mental health service usersí experience of mental health care. The high rate of CTO use needs to be addressed as a human rights issue as well as a clinical issue.








Human Services and Justice Coordinating Committee